让子弹飞 三刷

汤师爷 武智冲 胡万

仕。

利益至上的顶层官僚。协调和维持政权的重要力量。

郭沫若 钟南山 Humphery

张牧之

大哥。

左派理想主义的精神伟人。领导魅力(提供人民群众他们所需要的一切,见下),大局观(无论正确)。

毛泽东 孙中山 Caesar

二哥

二哥。

左派理想主义,有一定能力但是在阴影下(缺领导魅力),副手。

林彪 Labienus Antony

三四五七哥

幸存而有幸享受核心胜利果实(社会资源的分配权)的其他核心成员,左派现实主义者。

人各有志,有自己的利益诉求。

邓小平。

矛盾:左派不仅有理想主义者,也有现实主义者,左派里的右倾分子。左派的很多革命者不具备大哥那般维持革命的愿景,但又享有足够的社会利益,从屠龙者到恶龙的变质往往只是时间问题。

中国的人民群众

中国社会整体的统计概念。同样利益至上的群体,但和仕相对是弱势群体。

站队保守,避其锋芒,首先站队必赢的一方(大利害),然后再站队赢了对自己有利的一方(小利害)。不仅要被提供足够的动力(怒气),被提供足够的认识(王侯将相宁有种乎),被提供足够的安全感(斩首四郎),才会有所煽动。

2022的白纸抗议,有怒,有认识,有小利害,但是没有大利害,没有安全感。

枪打出头鸟,刑法的寻衅滋事条例,是防止人民群众敌对站队的核心工具,用风险对冲利害。

言论审查是防止怒气,认识的核心工具。

修宪连任本身不带来明显的权利,但这是斩首四郎的逆操作,一顶好帽子能剥离群众运动的一切安全感;“帝国主义不过是纸老虎”的社论才是斩首四郎的核心宣传。

很多上述性质并不局限在中国,特意提出是因为儒家尊崇的道德约束缺乏法制和契约的建制派土壤根基,群体事件的煽动促成几乎是一切社会革命的根本和归宿。在没有法制的地方,暴力的民主机器一旦失控带来的社会动荡往往是大多数人不能承受之重,所谓文革。

黄四郎

已经成为了恶龙的屠龙者。但何为恶龙,何为恶?背离了社会整体利益诉求,便是恶龙:善恶是人民群众的历史主观判别。在一般时代,被压迫的人民群众并不认为统治阶级是恶龙:只是寻常龙罢了。

革命背景下的右派核心。

袁世凯 蒋介石

专制政权和民主革命

县长代表的专制政权是暴力的民主革命力量,是人民群众眼中值得下跪的青天大老爷,是唯一能击败恶龙的勇者,是2000年朝代更迭轮回的根本原因。

没有专制政权,不能革命;但只要政权仍然专制,民主革命也就成功不了;但如果政权在人民群众契约认识不足的时候放手民主,文革也就指日可待了。

see also

《让子弹飞》的政治隐喻--毛泽东式的革命理想 - 中國論壇 - udn城市

《让子弹飞》《一步之遥》与《邪不压正》:革命,后革命与“前”革命 _ 赵皓阳 - RESSRC

乌克兰局势

2022-03-01

  1. 俄罗斯把乌克兰北东南三面合围以后不动了。既不合拢口袋,也不攻城。说明俄罗斯不着急。西乌部队肯定不会往口袋里钻,那无异于自杀。东乌政府军正面没有打赢的可能,长期来看除了撤退就是投降,没有别的选择。
  2. 俄罗斯没有切断乌西南即波兰罗马尼亚边境,甚至都没往西乌进军,尤其是北约武器现在在往西乌不断输送的情况下,说明俄对西乌没有任何兴趣。
  3. 表面上和乌克兰谈判但完全不停军事行动,说明俄罗斯没达到预期目标。
  4. 很多人说乌克兰会变成下一个阿富汗,我看未必。乌克兰地形缺乏打游击的条件,大平原重武器的对抗游击队根本活不了。乌克兰有抵抗意志但目前远没到阿富汗的血海深仇。

综合以上,俄罗斯在等乌东政府军撤离或者投降,把乌东自愿空出来。东西乌分治。剥离了重工业的西乌实际上失去了独立军事化的能力。东乌有亲俄文化和传统,扶持亲俄政府(可以就像现在这样打散);泽连斯基留在西乌。保留西乌是乌克兰民族分布导致的必然结果。

如果说前24小时的突进是希望乌克兰政府立即奔溃,那显然没达到目的,但不代表军事行动就没有意义了。目前还要打的是东西乌的分界线和对西乌停火的条件。

  1. 是否承认东乌各国独立
  2. 是否承诺永不入欧,永不入北约
  3. 是否承诺去军事化

东西乌分治后其实上述三个条件都不重要了,很有可能西乌一个都不会答应,继续要求加入欧盟北约。考虑到届时东西乌互为对方阵营缓冲带,西乌加入欧盟北约是真的有可能的。

Ukraine War

Countries

US

The biggest, if not only, winner of the event. The only one who wishes the event to happen, so that money can go back to US from EU (due to regional instability) to reduce the high inflation in US.

The only loss would be the confidence of US's allies accounting on its support.

If Russia does not invade Ukraine, NATO will be dancing at its doorstep which is super preferable to EU and US, but intolerable as to Russia.

If Russia invades Ukraine, EU and Russia will be against each other by sharing a military border, so that US (and UK) will have much less to worry about on these two opponents.

Russia

Has no advantage but military strength, has no means of diplomacy but threatening, has no choice but war. Pity.

European Union

Realize the event too late. Cannot do much. Now that Ukraine is under war, EU is bonded to US once more.

Ukraine

Stupid as fk. Lost everything because of some vague promise by US. Let war happen on its own soil due to some stupid and irresponsible politician breaching the status quo.

China

Cannot do anything. Cannot blame Ukraine as it's the victim. Cannot blame Russia since they are to some degree allies against US. Cannot defend Russia since Ukraine’s sovereign is threatened as a fact. Can blame US but few would listen, and the plot is just too good to believe.

Similar Event in History

Philippine on South China Sea

Stayed calm. Knows its position and is smart enough to avoid being used as pawns of US against China. US did not get anything but swear from Duterte to Obama.

Japan on Fishing Island

Japanese forced to lose its ground. US succeeded to break down the free trading pact between China and Japan.

South Korea on THAAD

Korea was forced to lose its ground. US succeeded to break down the free trading pact between China and South Korea.

Ukraine’s Only Options

Ukraine could be independent as North Korea if it did not give up its nuclear arsenal. Could be stable as Taiwan if it did not join any sides between NATO and Russia.

People

Zelenskyy

He is the main one accountable for this event due to lack of insight in foreign affairs and diplomacy status quo. He is not smart enough and has too much goodwill as the leader of a weak nation. He is bound to fail just as Allende in Chile.

If he dies he will become martyr of Ukraine Nationalism and neo-Nazism (ironically as a Jewish), and as an iron proof of Russia invasion. This is the last thing Russia would like to see, but the best thing US wants to see.

If he flees to US without public announcement he would probably be killed by US to fake the previous scenario.

If he flees to US with a public announcement, Ukraine Nationalism would suffer such a hit that Ukraine may just disappear as a country forever. The best thing Russia wants to see.

If he stays and is still the president after the Russian invasion, he will be a National traitor that sell his country to Russia.

In other words, his 'friends' wish he dies and his 'enemies' wish he lives.

Putin

He is what he is. He knows what Russia is good at and is not afraid to use its force when necessary. But honestly, he has no choice.

US Politicians

Still so good at manipulating the world.

Anti Chinese Sentiment

'Unfavorable views' of China reach historic highs, new report finds

Reality

It's been an issue since several years ago, or maybe longer as Wikipedia suggests. Last year when I was taking LP380 I discussed this problem with Prof. Ellan, a democrat. As most left-wing Americans would recognize such an issue and blame it on racism, it's not within their power to solve it. There are way more people holding different options, no matter holding themselves as racist or not.